Neutering to reduce anxiety?

Behavioral Issues

  • @Quercus:

    Just food for thought…it is widely believed that dogs don't regard their own sexuality the way humans do. Most likely, Kananga wouldn't be happier, or less happy if he were neutered...he would have no idea.

    I would like to know (honestly, I don't know) what health risks (aside from anesthesia) there are to neutering a dog. We can start a new thread, if you wish...but I am really curious.

    In regards to him being unchanged with happiness, that's my point. If it makes no difference with him then why do some people say he will be happier?

    With what i've read, these were the most common results in studies (to name a few):

    -3x risk of hypothyroidism (my vet has also confirmed this with me)
    -Increases the risk of progressive geriatric cognitive impairment
    -3x risk of obesity
    -Increases the risk of prostate cancer (albeit there's an obvious reduction in testicular cancer)
    -Increases the risk of bone cancer
    -General physical complications with the surgery (small percentage, but still a risk)


  • @Kananga:

    In regards to him being unchanged with happiness, that's my point. If it makes no difference with him then why do some people say he will be happier?

    I think they are saying he'd be happier because he won't be a slave to his hormones…he'd be more balanced that way and less anxious when there is a dog in season.

  • Houston

    I agree with the posts stating he might not necessarily be happy just because you have him neutered. Give the DAP an honest try and if that doesn't work try some other things before you jump into conclusion that a neuter is a cure all. I feel, like you that this is a personal issue between you and Kananga. I haven't done the research about pros and cons of neutering but seeing what you wrote about the hypothyroidism and all that I will. I have had 2 other dogs in the past and they were both neutered, one of the became very overweight regardless of what I fed him ( well, that is not true, when he was on Barf he did great), and my other dog got hypothyroidism and cancer (brain though).
    Good luck, and keep us updated on how he turns out on the DAP.

    Petra


  • @renaultf1:

    I think they are saying he'd be happier because he won't be a slave to his hormones…he'd be more balanced that way and less anxious when there is a dog in season.

    To which I do honestly understand. But with a more balanced nature, the 3x risk of hypothyroidism could mean one problem fixed and one problem created.

    That's how I look at it.


  • @Kananga:

    In regards to him being unchanged with happiness, that's my point. If it makes no difference with him then why do some people say he will be happier?

    With what i've read, these were the most common results in studies (to name a few):

    -3x risk of hypothyroidism (my vet has also confirmed this with me)
    -Increases the risk of progressive geriatric cognitive impairment
    -3x risk of obesity
    -Increases the risk of prostate cancer (albeit there's an obvious reduction in testicular cancer)
    -Increases the risk of bone cancer
    -General physical complications with the surgery (small percentage, but still a risk)

    I totally disagree with the 3x risk of obesity… my males that were neutered were never over weight, nor were my bitches. Basenjis are quite pre-disposed to hypothyroidism, neutered or not, spayed or not.... and while as said there are pros and cons on both side, you could make the case for each one of them on both sides of the fence. So it is up to each person to make the decision that works for them. For me, as a breeder, I am quite comfortable with my decisions to spay/neuter and to place all pets on spay/neuter contracts.


  • @Quercus:

    I would like to know (honestly, I don't know) what health risks (aside from anesthesia) there are to neutering a dog. We can start a new thread, if you wish…but I am really curious.

    This is a link that I found pretty interesting on this topic. BTW, I'm not advocating one way or another…I just found this article interesting.
    http://www.naiaonline.org/pdfs/LongTermHealthEffectsOfSpayNeuterInDogs.pdf

    My only opinion on this matter is this: as much responsibility as it is to have a pet - period, it is even that much more responsibility to have an intact animal…especially when it comes to making sure that it doesn't get free and isn't allowed to roam or run unsupervised...


  • @tanza:

    I totally disagree with the 3x risk of obesity… my males that were neutered were never over weight, nor were my bitches. Basenjis are quite pre-disposed to hypothyroidism, neutered or not, spayed or not.... and while as said there are pros and cons on both side, you could make the case for each one of them on both sides of the fence. So it is up to each person to make the decision that works for them. For me, as a breeder, I am quite comfortable with my decisions to spay/neuter and to place all pets on spay/neuter contracts.

    Risk is simply that, it's risk. It varies by breed but the research done was with various breeds and multiple dogs.

    I'm not in any way saying neutering is bad. My point is that leaving a dog intact is not 100% wrong. It's a marginal difference when you weigh our the risks and benefits for both cases. Some may say neutering imposes more risk, some may say leaving them intact imposes more risk.

    I agree with you about going with what works best for them. For me, Kananga will never be out in the open on his own. There's no social risk. So it all comes down to behavior/health.

    I don't fault anyone for their decisions, unless its a dead giveaway that it was a poor choice (i.e. leaving a male intact that is around intact females unsupervised and no intentions of breeding).


  • @renaultf1:

    This is a link that I found pretty interesting on this topic. BTW, I'm not advocating one way or another…I just found this article interesting.
    http://www.naiaonline.org/pdfs/LongTermHealthEffectsOfSpayNeuterInDogs.pdf

    My only opinion on this matter is this: as much responsibility as it is to have a pet - period, it is even that much more responsibility to have an intact animal…especially when it comes to making sure that it doesn't get free and isn't allowed to roam or run unsupervised...

    That is one of my sources of information.

    Precisely.


  • I do believe there is a way to chemically neuter your dog that is not a permanent thing. This might be worth a try if you're really wondering if neutering would change him. Of course I don't have any information on this, but i'm sure if you google "chemical neuter" something would pop up. And you'd probably have to travel to find a vet who is savvy about this.


  • Kananga - when I leave my dogs alone in the house I use a CD on repeat. The CD is called 'Relaxation Music for your Dog'. It is very effective in keeping them calm. I think I got it from Crosskeys. The producers are Omnibus Media and their web address is www.musicsales.com I can also endorse the Dap which I have found effective in calming my dogs when necessary.


  • @Patty:

    Kananga - when I leave my dogs alone in the house I use a CD on repeat. The CD is called 'Relaxation Music for your Dog'. It is very effective in keeping them calm. I think I got it from Crosskeys. The producers are Omnibus Media and their web address is www.musicsales.com I can also endorse the Dap which I have found effective in calming my dogs when necessary.

    Interesting. You know the long drive back I had when I initially picked him up (2 hour drive home) I had classical music playing which really put him into a deep sleep on the car ride. Ever since he's always calm around that same music.

    I should give that a try. :D


  • Day 1 was an interesting test. I did not expect any results for at least a few weeks.

    I came home, nothing was moved, he had a big smile on his face, and he was extremely mellow when I was taking him outside. Normally he seems a bit distracted outside, but today he was just easy going. Actually got a bit vocal with me outside (few roos) which I have never had him do on a short walk.

    We'll see how the next few weeks go. :D


  • Proof of the big smile (he only does this when he's had a long walk, so it's the first I've seen with no walk):

    It's strange, he is acting differently. But in a good way. :D


  • @Kananga:

    Day 1 was an interesting test. I did not expect any results for at least a few weeks.

    I came home, nothing was moved, he had a big smile on his face, and he was extremely mellow when I was taking him outside. Normally he seems a bit distracted outside, but today he was just easy going. Actually got a bit vocal with me outside (few roos) which I have never had him do on a short walk.

    We'll see how the next few weeks go. :D

    Day one of what? The DAP?


  • @Quercus:

    Day one of what? The DAP?

    Yep. It's been on for about 24 hours now.

  • Houston

    wow, that Dap is something else. I will keep my fingers crossed that it keeps up.

    Petra


  • D'uh, music, of course. don't know why i didn't think of that. i've taught several control unleashed class and night one i recommend several cu compatable things, one of which is:

    http://www.throughadogsear.com/

    I have the book/cd combo and i assure my students that the cute basenjis on the cover had nothing (well, almost nothing) to do with me checking the book out from the library, which I later bought.


  • Kananga - glad that the DAP seems to be working. If you do decide to go with the CD.
    I checked and they are still available on crosskeysbooks.com - click Dogs-Dog Therapy CD page.


  • While I agree with the reasons others have mentioned in favor of neutering, I am not convinced your dog's anxiety is hormone related. Personally I think continued use of the DAP along with some serious exercise to get rid of some of his tension would be the best route to take at this point. Another thing is to never make coming home or leaving home a big deal. I don't know how you handle either but many people make the mistake of "working the dog up" with a rousing goodbye or hello and this builds excitement or anxiety in a dog. If you are calm and give off good vibes the dog should pick up on this and it may help calm them also.


  • Good thoughts Robyn… and that is true... the less you make out of coming and/or going the more they will think it is not a big deal... Mine rarely would get out of bed in the morning when I left for work..gggg and if they did, they would then go beg Dad to put them back under the covers....

Suggested Topics

  • More stranger anxiety!

    Behavioral Issues
    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    6k Views
    J
    Completely agree with you thunderbird! I'm glad to here that Malaika is doing well–there is hope!! :) . Control Unleashed has a lot of strategies (e.g. the Look At That game & hand targets) that I hope will make an impact. Keep us updated on your efforts!
  • Anxiety wrap on sale

    Behavioral Issues
    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    1k Views
    No one has replied
  • Separation Anxiety?

    Behavioral Issues
    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    5k Views
    Shaye's MomS
    Your situation sounds like mine was, when we had only Shaye. She had a serious case of separation anxiety and the minute we tried leaving, she would pee, wherever she was, along with screaming. Everyone told us to get her another b, and when we got Gemma, it was magic. So long as Gemma is with her, she is fine. Maybe Aries just feels more secure with Katie than with Petey. Is Petey less calm than Katie?
  • Anxiety from loneliness…

    Behavioral Issues
    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    3k Views
    thunderbird8588T
    Awwww poor Ginger i feel so sad for her and you having to cope. All i can suggest is lots and lots of TLC and perhaps another companion if you can cope and the time is right. Do you have to have a cover on top of the crate? If not it is one less thing for her to destroy.
  • Anxiety help

    Behavioral Issues
    36
    0 Votes
    36 Posts
    8k Views
    renaultf1R
    @sharronhurlbut: Re car rides, this is going to sound odd, but it does work for me and my 2 dogs. Even if you have walked your dogs before a car trip, I find the excitement of the "get into the car" and going makes there guts act up. So, here is what we do. We take the dogs a lot on vacation when we go by car. We walk the dogs in the am, feed and water. Get them into the car. Drive about 2 miles and stop and let them out to walk. Both always pee and poo when we stop. Once back in the car, they settle and are quiet. About a hr or so into the ride, they start to get "ACTIVE" again…we stop at a rest area, they go, and then they sleep the rest of the way. Could be the excitement of leaving home, the motion of the car or whatever, but these stops, even tho you want to get going...make the trip much easier on all involved. Give it a try. All you can lose is a bit of time... Sharron…I've had friends use that method as well...so I think you (and them) are on to something. Wizard...It is a tough road, separation anxiety. I never had much success with the DAP - spray or plug-in...and I used both for about half a year. I finally gave up on it. Although, my vet and the pet store I bought it at said they knew of people that had had success with it. Good for you for working with a behaviorist...they definitely will have better ideas about things to try. The second beastie was the golden ticket for Ruby though...and seriously, I've found that 2 b's are so much easier than one. So much so that I'm thinking of adding another either this year or next...and for that I might need my head examined.
  • Separation Anxiety Advice

    Behavioral Issues
    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    3k Views
    WBLW
    There is a light at the end, but with some dogs it can be farther away. I had a boxer a few yrs ago that had it really bad, and after lots of crate training and patients she was able to stay in her crate. She would make such horrible noises she sounded like a fog horn. And she'd pee in her crate or poop in and then step all in. IMO, I don't thing Lola needs medication. It can be quite frustrating, but biggest thing is lots of patients to train her that you will be back and it is okay to hang out by herself. Also, since she is not destructive but is pooping when you leave, make sure she gets a good walk or play session where you know she has gone potty. I'd take out the treats, that gives something to put in that must come out. You can give simple treats or things that need worked on like a kong stuffed with soemthing tastey and frozen so it'll take work for her to eat it all. Here are some links with articles on seperation anxiety. http://www.wagntrain.com/SeparationAnx.htm http://www.usask.ca/wcvm/herdmed/applied-ethology/behaviourproblems/anxiety.html http://www.hsus.org/pets/pet_care/our_pets_for_life_program/dog_behavior_tip_sheets/separation_anxiety.html